We had no tartar sauce to go with the fishies we caught, so I had to improvise.
Essentially this is making a mayonnaise and then converting it into tartar sauce. You could start with mayo and jump to step , but the homemade mayo tastes a lot better.
This recipe can be doubled or tippled as needed, but this amount was good for 4 servings.
- One egg yolk
- 1 tsp of lemon juice or white wine vinegar
- Salt
- Pepper
- .5 c extra virgin olive oil
- .5 c non-fat, plain yogurt
- .25 c chopped dill pickles
- lemon juice to taste
- hot sauce (optional)
- Put the yolk, lemon juice or vinegar, salt and pepper in a bowl. You’ll need a decent size one to get enough whisk action to emulsify the ingredients. That means something at least twice as big as a cereal bowl.
- Whisk like crazy while slowly adding a few drops of oil to the mixture. Increase the flow to a light drizzle. The oil should be mixing into the egg at this point and thickening. If you just have oily yolk, you added too much oil too quickly or didn’t whisk fast enough. Keep adding the oil until it’s all worked in. That’s mayo. It’ll be much more yellow than Hellman’s, but that’s because they probably use Clorox bleach in theirs.
- Fold in the yogurt and pickles. You can add a little minced garlic if you want too at this point.
- Season with salt and pepper to taste. Add more lemon juice or hot sauce or anything else that would be good in there tasting as you go.
















